Theory of Knowledge
Theory of Knowledge
13
Chapters
165
Notes
Chapter 1 - Knowledge & The Knower(Core)
Chapter 1 - Knowledge & The Knower(Core)
Chapter 2 - Knowledge & Technology(Optional)
Chapter 2 - Knowledge & Technology(Optional)
Chapter 3 - Knowledge & Language(Optional)
Chapter 3 - Knowledge & Language(Optional)
Chapter 4 - Knowledge & Politics(Optional)
Chapter 4 - Knowledge & Politics(Optional)
Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)
Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)
Chapter 6 - Knowledge & Indigenous Societies(Optional)
Chapter 6 - Knowledge & Indigenous Societies(Optional)
Chapter 7 - History(AoK)
Chapter 7 - History(AoK)
Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 9 - The Natural Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 9 - The Natural Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 10 - The Arts(AoK)
Chapter 10 - The Arts(AoK)
Chapter 11 - Mathematics(AoK)
Chapter 11 - Mathematics(AoK)
Chapter 12 - ToK Exhibition
Chapter 12 - ToK Exhibition
Chapter 13 - ToK Essay
Chapter 13 - ToK Essay
IB Resources
Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)
Theory of Knowledge
Theory of Knowledge

Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)

The Fallibility of Human Sciences: An Insightful Dive

Word Count Emoji
755 words
Reading Time Emoji
4 mins read
Updated at Emoji
Last edited on 5th Nov 2024

Table of content

Introduction to human sciences experimentation

Human sciences like psychology often utilize experimentation. However, certain disciplines such as economics and political science find it challenging to conduct controlled experiments.

 

Fun Fact: Why is this? Well, it's mostly because these disciplines deal with complex systems, where controlling every variable is impossible. Think of trying to control every single factor in a country's economy - pretty impossible, right?

 

But there's a twist - the knowledge we gain from these experiments can help predict policy outcomes and reforms.

Value and challenges of experiments

Experiments do hold value, as shown by psychology and behavioural economics through randomized controlled trials. But, it's like walking on thin ice - experimental evidence can sometimes be misunderstood, and it might even give us a false sense of certainty.

 

Example Time: Remember the disastrous effects of over-relying on mathematical models in economics? Yeah, that's what we're talking about.

 

Moreover, sampling issues like the WEIRD bias (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic societies' overrepresentation) can muddy the water, causing problems in our knowledge pool.

The case of the rat park study

Here comes a story of rats, drugs, and parks! Bruce Alexander’s “rat park” study revolutionized how we perceive addiction - shifting blame from individual's moral and mental failings to social dislocation. This knowledge, however, was ignored while governments persisted with their "war on drugs."

 

Real-World Example: It's like if you're given a banana but keep asking for an apple, even when the apple's rotten.

 

Despite attempts to replicate the rat park study's results and some concerns about the experiment's design, there's now a broader (though not universal) acceptance that we need more compassion for people struggling with addiction.

Unlock the Full Content! File Is Locked Emoji

Dive deeper and gain exclusive access to premium files of Theory of Knowledge. Subscribe now and get closer to that 45 🌟

Nail IB's App Icon
IB Resources
Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)
Theory of Knowledge
Theory of Knowledge

Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)

The Fallibility of Human Sciences: An Insightful Dive

Word Count Emoji
755 words
Reading Time Emoji
4 mins read
Updated at Emoji
Last edited on 5th Nov 2024

Table of content

Introduction to human sciences experimentation

Human sciences like psychology often utilize experimentation. However, certain disciplines such as economics and political science find it challenging to conduct controlled experiments.

 

Fun Fact: Why is this? Well, it's mostly because these disciplines deal with complex systems, where controlling every variable is impossible. Think of trying to control every single factor in a country's economy - pretty impossible, right?

 

But there's a twist - the knowledge we gain from these experiments can help predict policy outcomes and reforms.

Value and challenges of experiments

Experiments do hold value, as shown by psychology and behavioural economics through randomized controlled trials. But, it's like walking on thin ice - experimental evidence can sometimes be misunderstood, and it might even give us a false sense of certainty.

 

Example Time: Remember the disastrous effects of over-relying on mathematical models in economics? Yeah, that's what we're talking about.

 

Moreover, sampling issues like the WEIRD bias (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic societies' overrepresentation) can muddy the water, causing problems in our knowledge pool.

The case of the rat park study

Here comes a story of rats, drugs, and parks! Bruce Alexander’s “rat park” study revolutionized how we perceive addiction - shifting blame from individual's moral and mental failings to social dislocation. This knowledge, however, was ignored while governments persisted with their "war on drugs."

 

Real-World Example: It's like if you're given a banana but keep asking for an apple, even when the apple's rotten.

 

Despite attempts to replicate the rat park study's results and some concerns about the experiment's design, there's now a broader (though not universal) acceptance that we need more compassion for people struggling with addiction.

Unlock the Full Content! File Is Locked Emoji

Dive deeper and gain exclusive access to premium files of Theory of Knowledge. Subscribe now and get closer to that 45 🌟