Mathematics AA HL
Mathematics AA HL
Sample Internal Assessment
Sample Internal Assessment
6/7
6/7
11 mins Read
11 mins Read
2,079 Words
2,079 Words
English
English
Free
Free

Investigation on the effect of angle of projection, wind current & air resistance in the game of javelin throw

Table of content

Rationale

My favorite subject is science. I find it very interesting. Science can be applied everywhere in our day to day life and this is what makes it interesting for me.

 

I am a sports jock and have always taken interest in it. I have participated in school sports even from the very 1st grade. I play football quite well. I am in the school's football team as well. But it is not only football that I play, I tend to play any sport that I get a chance.

 

For this year's sports, a friend of mine gave his name for javelin throw. I accompanied him to his practice where I tried playing it as well. I quite enjoyed it and somehow my friend convinced me to give my name for javelin throw in the sport's day.

 

I take every sport seriously. I try my best to play well and so I could not take this casually. I started practicing for javelin throw. A game is not just learning to play on the field, there is a lot theory behind it. Understanding and applying it, is very important to perfect a game.

 

I had to do the same with javelin throw. Field practice would be perfect only if I could master the theoretical concept. So, I started finding out information about this sport.  There was science to it and I read all available information with great interest. I came to know about the spear and quite a number of tips about the game, but I could not get the answer to the question that bothered me the most.

 

While practicing on field, I at times found it difficult to manage during wind and I also had no idea about the angle of projection. The question that I was trying to find was that to what extent the angle of projection of spear during javelin throw and wind speed acting in horizontal direction as that of the projection of the spear, affect the range of the projectile.

 

So, I have decided to research on the above stated question and this is what the IA is all about.

Aim

The main motive of this IA is to study the trajectory of Javelin throw and explore the effect of angle of projection of the throw in winning the game. As javelin is played in open field, air resistance and air current are two uncontrolled variable that may affect the game. Thus, another motive of this IA, in addition to the study of angle of projection, is to investigate the effect of wind current in a direction same as that of the direction of horizontal motion of javelin throw and that of the opposite direction as well. Finally, I will find the effect of air resistance in the trajectory of Javelin Throw.

Research question

To what extent does the angle of projection of javelin throw, wind speed acting in horizontal direction as that of the projection of javelin, and air resistance affect the range of the projectile (javelin)?

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Introduction

    Javelin throw is one of the most watched and interesting games in athletics. The winning factor of the game is the distance the javelin has covered in a single throw. The one whose range of javelin throw is maximum, wins the game. In the game, there are several parameters on which the range of the javelin depends. It depends on the initial velocity of throw and also the direction of projection. We know that, maximum the initial velocity of throw will be, more the distance the javelin will cover but the effect of angle of projection will be studied in this IA. As, with stepper angle of projection, the javelin cannot cover a larger distance and same for flatter angle of projection. A few equations of motion in physics are very essential in this IA. The relationship between displacement and time will be extensively used in the process of calculation and thus it is shown below:

     

    s = ut + \(\frac{1}{2}\)at2………(1)

     

    where, s is the displacement done by the body, u is the initial velocity of the body, a is acceleration of the body, and t is time.

     

    As we know that, with increased velocity of javelin, the range of the projectile will also increase. As javelin throw game has been played in open ground, the air current may increase the velocity of the javelin which will earn more range and become a favorable factor for the player. Similarly, variable velocity may offer different aspects compared to the other players in the game. Furthermore, if the wind is blowing in opposite direction as that of the horizontal direction of javelin, then the velocity of javelin will decrease which will eventually decrease the range of javelin and being a disadvantage for the player. As a result, the evaluation of the game will be biased. This is due to relative velocity. So, in this IA, we will study the effect of wind current in velocity of javelin resulting in achieving different range. The basic formulation of relative velocity which will be essential in the proceedings of this IA are as follows:

     

    If the direction of wind is exactly equal to that of the horizontal direction of javelin throw, then, vj being the initial velocity of javelin and vw be the velocity of wind, the effective velocity of javelin will be:

     

    veff  = vj + vw………(2)

     

    Similarly, if the direction of wind is exactly opposite to that of the horizontal direction of javelin throw, then, vj being the initial velocity of javelin and vw be the velocity of wind, the effective velocity of javelin will be:

     

    veff = |vj - vw|………(3)

     

    Air Resistance is the resistive force that is experienced by any moving object through air medium. It is due to the friction that takes place between the air molecules and the moving object. The formula of Air Resistance is shown as follows:

     

    F = \(\frac{\rho C_DA}{2}×v^2\)

     

    where, F is the resistive force (Air Resistance), ρ is density of air, CD is drag coefficient, A is the area of cross section of moving object, and v is velocity of the object.

    Mathematical tools used

    Derivation of Displacement – Time Equation

     

    In this IA, we will be using the equation (1) for derivation of the equation of range of trajectory of javelin. The derivation of equation (1) is shown below:

     

    From the definition of velocity, we know that, “rate of change of displacement or the change of displacement of any body in unit time is velocity”. Moreover, acceleration is defined as, “rate of change of velocity”. Therefore, from the definition of acceleration, we can write,

     

    \(a=\frac{v-u}{t}\)

     

    where, a is the acceleration, u is the initial velocity, v is the final velocity and t is the time for which the body was in motion.

     

    ∴ v = u + at

     

    Again, from the definition of velocity, we can write

     

    \(v=\frac{S_f-s_i}{t}\)

     

    where, sf is the final displacement, si is the initial displacement of the body.

     

    For very small instant of time, we can write,

     

    \(\frac{ds}{dt}=v\)

     

    \(=>\frac{ds}{dt}=u+at\)

     

    => ds = udt + atdt

     

    \(=>\displaystyle\int ds = \displaystyle\int udt +\displaystyle\int atdt\)

     

    => s = ut + \(\frac{1}{2}\,at^2 +c\)

     

    Here, c is the integration constant which can be defined as the initial displacement of the body. If there is no initial displacement, i.e., c = 0, then we can conclude:

     

    \(s=ut+\frac{1}{2}at^2\)

     

    In vertical axis, let the modified form of equation (1) be written as:

     

    \(s_y=u_yt+\frac{1}{2}a_yt^2\)………(4)

     

    In horizontal axis, let the modified form of equation (1) be written as:

     

    \(s_x = u_x t + \frac{1}{2}a_xt^2\)………(5)

     

    Parametric values: As the net displacement in vertical direction in a javelin throw is zero, and the acceleration is due to gravity, the respective values will be:

     

    s= 0 m; a= - 9.81 m/s2

     

    Similarly, the net displacement in horizontal direction in a javelin throw is the range which is the dependent variable of this IA. Let the range be R, and the acceleration in horizontal direction is zero. Thus, the respective values will be:

     

    Sx = R m; ax = 0 m/s2

     

    Resolution of vector: Resolution of vector is a mathematical tool using which the horizontal component and the vertical component of any vector is found out. In case of javelin throw, it is thrown at an angle with some initial velocity; which implies that the initial velocity has a definite direction. If the initial velocity of projection makes an angle of \(\theta\) with respect to the horizontal axis, then:

    Figure 1 - Symbolic Representation Of Trajectory Of Javelin

    From figure 1, blue arrow is the direction of projection thus, we can redraw the section to mathematically derive the horizontal and vertical component of velocity.

    Figure 2 - Representation Of Velocity Components

    From figure 2, we can write,

     

    sin \(sin\,\theta=\frac{AB}{OA}=\frac{OC}{OA}=\frac{u_y}{u}\)

     

    => uy = u× sin sin \(\theta\)  ………(6)

     

    cos \(cos\,\theta=\frac{OB}{OA}=\frac{U_X}{U}\)

     

    => ux = u× cos cos \(\theta\) ………(7)

     

    Derivation using concepts of solving simultaneous equation:

    Using equation (4), (6) and the parametric values, we can write,

     

    sy = uy t + \(\frac{1}{2}\)ay gt2

     

    => 0 = u× sin sin \(\theta\) ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)gt2

     

    => \(\biggl(\)2u × sin sin \(\theta\) ×t - gt2\(\biggl)\) = 0

     

    => (2u × sin sin \(\theta\)  - gt) × t = 0

     

    ∴ t = 0

     

    ∴ 2u × sin sin \(\theta\) - gt = 0

     

    => t = \(\frac{2u\,×\,sin\,sin \,\theta }{g}\)

     

    This implies, at these two-time instances, the vertical displacement will be zero. Thus, the total time of flight will be:

     

    T = \(\frac{2u\,×\,sin\,sin \,\theta }{g}\)

     

    Now using equation (5), (7) and the parametric values, we can write:

     

    s= ut + \(\frac{1}{2}\)ayt2

     

    => R = uT + \(\frac{1}{2}\)× (0) × T2

     

    Here, R is the range and T is the total time period or total time of flight.

     

    ∴ R = uT

     

    => R = u× cos cos \(\theta\) × \(\frac{2u×sin sin \,\theta }{g}\)

     

    => R = \(\frac{u^2×2sin sin \,\theta\, coscos\, \theta }{g}\)

     

    => R = \(\frac{u^2×sin sin \,2\theta }{g}\)………(8)

     

    Maxima and Minima of calculus:

    If a function f(x) is differentiated with respect to x, then the derivative will be the slope of the curve f(x). Now, if the derivative is equated to zero, it implies that the slope of the curve is a line which is parallel to the X – Axis because slope of a straight line can be defined as the tangent of angle that the straight line makes with positive X – Axis. Now, at two instances, the slope of a curve could be parallel to the horizontal axis. Those are, either the slope is at maximum value of the curve or at the minimum value of the curve. To determine that, the derivate is differentiated again with respect to x. If the value of the derivative is positive, then the obtained slope was at minimum value of the curve and if the value of the derivative is negative, then the obtained slope was at the maximum value of the curve.

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Process of calculation

    Investigation on the effect of angle of projection:

    The match which I have seen, the velocity of projection of the athlete was 30 m/s.

     

    Therefore, we can compute the value and establish an equation of range as follows:

     

    R = \(\frac{u^2×sinsin\, 2\theta}{g}\)

     

    R = \(\frac{30^2×sinsin\, 2\theta}{9.81}\)

     

    => R =  \(\frac{900×sinsin\, 2\theta}{9.81}\)

     

    R = 91.74 × sin 2 ………(9)

     

    Now, we will use Desmos to show graphically the variation of range due to angle or projection.

    Figure 3 - Variation Of Range With Respect To Angle In Radian

    From the graph, we can find that the range of javelin depends on the angle of projection in sinusoidal nature, provided the angle should be acute.

     

    To find the maximum range, the concept of maxima and minima will be used. I will differentiate the equation no (9) with respect to \(\theta\), to find the value of angle of projection for which the range will be maximum.

     

    R = 91.74× sin sin 2θ

     

    \(\frac{dR}{d\theta}=\frac{d}{d\theta}\)(91.74× sin sin 2θ )

     

    => \(\frac{dR}{d\theta}\) = 91.74× \(\frac{d}{d\theta}\)(sin sin 2θ )

     

    => \(\frac{dR}{d\theta}\)= 91.74× 2× cos cos 2θ

     

    => 0 = 183.48× cos cos 2θ

     

    => cos cos 2θ = 0

     

    => 2θ = \(\frac{\pi}{2}\)

     

    => θ = \(\frac{\pi}{4}\)

     

    Therefore, for maximum range, the angle of projection should be \(\frac{\pi}{4}\) or 45°

     

    Investigation on the effect of wind speed:

    To establish the effect of wind in Javelin throw, I have shown a data to cite the range of values of wind speed that often interact with the velocity of the javelin:

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Serial No.
    Year
    Wind Speed (m/s)
    1
    2008
    4.1
    2
    2013
    5.0
    3
    2013
    1.8
    4
    1990
    4.0
    5
    1979
    3.5
    6
    1989
    2.6
    7
    1995
    1.2
    8
    1991
    2.9
    9
    1991
    0.3
    10
    1991
    4.4
    11
    2009
    4.0
    12
    2009
    4.1
    Figure 4 - Table On Wind Assistance In Games

    From the above-mentioned data, we can see that, wind speed that affects the game ranges up to 5 m/sec. Thus, in this IA, we will consider a range of wind speed from null to 5 m/sec in both the directions that of the horizontal direction of the javelin throw.

     

    Wind is flowing in the direction as that of the javelin:

    The match which I have seen, the velocity of projection of the athlete was 30 m/s. As, wind speed is a variable in this case study, we will take a constant value of the angle of projection. As we have studied that in the previous section that range will be maximum for angle of projection equal to 45°, the angle of projection will be made constant in this section of the IA and equal to 45°.

     

    Therefore, we can compute the value and establish an equation of range as follows:

     

    R = \(\frac{u^2×sinsin\,2\theta}{g}\)

     

    => Rmax\(\frac{u^2×sinsin\,(2×45)°}{g}=\frac{u^2×1}{g}=\frac{u^2}{g}\)

     

    Here, u is the combined velocity of javelin and wind. From equation (2), we can write,

     

    u = ui + uw

     

    => u = 30 + uw

    Serial No.
    Wind Speed (in m/s)
    Effective Velocity (in m/s)
    Range (in m)
    1
    0.5
    30.5
    94.82671
    2
    1
    31
    97.96126
    3
    1.5
    31.5
    101.1468
    4
    2
    32
    104.3833
    5
    2.5
    32.5
    107.6707
    6
    3
    33
    111.0092
    7
    3.5
    33.5
    114.3986
    8
    4
    34
    117.8389
    9
    4.5
    34.5
    121.3303
    10
    5
    35
    124.8726
    Figure 5 - Table On Range Of Javelin For Different Wind Speed

    Sample Calculation:

     

    Effective Velocity = (30 + 0.5) m/sec = 30.5 m/sec

     

    Range = \(\frac{30.5^2}{9.891}=\frac{930.25}{9.81}\) = 94.82 m

     

    Wind is flowing in the direction opposite to that of the javelin:

    The match which I have seen, the velocity of projection of the athlete was 30 m/s. As, wind speed is a variable in this case study, we will take a constant value of the angle of projection. As we have studied that in the previous section that range will be maximum for angle of projection equal to 45°, the angle of projection will be made constant in this section of the IA and equal to 45°.

     

    Therefore, we can compute the value and establish an equation of range as follows:

     

    \(R=\frac{u^2×sinsin\,2\theta}{g}\)

     

    => Rmax \(\frac{u^2×sinsin(2×45)°}{g}=\frac{u^2×1}{g}=\frac{u^2}{g}\)

     

    Here, u is the combined velocity of javelin and wind. From equation (2), we can write,

     

    \(u=\biggl{|}u_i-u_w\biggl{|}\)

     

    => u = 10 - uw

    Serial No.
    Wind Speed (in m/s)
    Effective Velocity (in m/s)
    Range (in m)
    1
    0.5
    29.5
    88.7105
    2
    1
    29
    85.72885
    3
    1.5
    28.5
    82.79817
    4
    2
    28
    79.91845
    5
    2.5
    27.5
    77.0897
    6
    3
    27
    74.31193
    7
    3.5
    26.5
    71.58512
    8
    4
    26
    68.90928
    9
    4.5
    25.5
    66.2844
    10
    5
    25
    63.7105
    Figure 6 - Table On Range Of Javelin For Different Wind Speed

    Sample Calculation:

     

    Effective Velocity = (30 - 0.5) m/sec = 29.5 m/sec

     

    Range = \(\frac{29.5^2}{9.81}=\frac{870.25}{9.81}=88.71\, m\)

     

    Investigation on trajectory of Javelin:

    We know that from equation 4 and 5,

     

    \(S_x=u_x\,t+\frac{1}{2}a_xt^2\)

     

    => sx = u cos cos \(\theta\) ×t

     

    => x = u cos cos \(\theta\) ×t

     

    \(S_y=u_y\,t+\frac{1}{2}a_yt^2\)

     

    => y = u sin sin \(\theta\) ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)gt2

     

    => y = u sin sin \(\theta\) × \(\frac{x}{ucoscos\,\theta}-\frac{1}{2}g(\frac{x}{ucoscos\,\theta})^2\)

     

    => y = \(\frac{x}{tantan\,\theta}-\frac{1}{2}g(\frac{x}{ucoscos\,\theta})^2\)

     

    Investigation of Air Resistance on Javelin:

    We know that,

     

    v = u + at

     

    v= u- gt

     

    => v= u sin sin \(\theta\) - gt

     

    Therefore, Air Resistance in Y- Direction:

     

    In general case, the values of the different parameters are as follows:

     

    \(\rho\) = 0.45Kg.m-3 \(\biggl|\)C= 0.025\(\biggl|\)

     

    Radius of cross section of javelin = 0.0238 m

     

    Area of cross section of javelin = \(\pi\)r2 = 3. 414 × 0. 0232 = 0. 00179 m2

     

    \(F=\frac{\rho C_DA}{2}×v^2\)

     

    \(=>F= \frac{(0.45)(0.025)(0.00179)}{2}×v^2_y\)

     

    => F = 0. 000402 × \(v^2_y\)

     

    Let us consider that the velocity of projection is 30 m/sec and the angle of projection is 45°, then the air resistance will vary as shown below:

     

    => F = 0. 000402 × (u sin sin \(\theta\) - gt)2

     

     => F = 0. 000402 × (30 sin sin 45 - 9.81t)2

     

    => F = 0. 1809 - 0. 167t + 0. 0386t2

     

    Again,

     

    v = u + at

     

    vx = ux

     

    => vx = u cos cos \(\theta\)

     

    Therefore, Air Resistance in X- Direction:

     

    \(F=\frac{\rho C_DA}{2}\) × v2

     

    => F = \(\frac{(0.45)(0.025)(0.00179)}{2}×v^2_x\)

     

    => F = 0. 000402 × \(v^2_x\)

     

    Let us consider that the velocity of projection is 30 m/sec and the angle of projection is 45°, then the air resistance will vary as shown below:

     

    => F = 0. 000402 × (u cos cos \(\theta\))2

     

    => F = 0. 000402 × (30 cos cos 45)2

     

    => F = 0. 1809 N

     

    Mass of Javelin = 0.081 Kg10

     

    Negative acceleration in X Axis = \(\frac{0.1809}{0.015}\) = 2. 21 m/s2

     

    Therefore, final velocity in X Axis = u cos cos \(\theta\)  - 2. 21t

     

    Negative acceleration in Y Axis = \(\frac{0.1809-0.167t+0.0386t^2}{0.0815}\)(2. 21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t2) m/s2

     

    Therefore, final velocity in Y Axis = u sin sin \(\theta\) - (2. 21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t2 + g)t

     

    Trajectory of Javelin with Air resistance:

     

    We know that from equation 4 and 5,

     

    \(S_x = u_xt+\frac{1}{2}a_xt^2\)

     

    => s= u cos cos \(\theta\) ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)(2.21)t2

     

    => x = u cos cos \(\theta\) ×t - 1. 105t2…(10)

     

    \(S_y = u_yt+\frac{1}{2}a_yt^2\)

     

    => y = u sin sin \(\theta\) ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\) \(\biggl(\)2. 21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t+ g\(\biggl)\)t2…(11)

     

    Here we will consider three angles of projection.

     

    In first case, angle of projection is equal to 30° and initial velocity is 30 m/sec.

     

    From equation 10, we can write

     

    x = 30 × cos cos 30° ×t - 1. 105t2

     

    => x = 15 \(\sqrt{3t}-1.105t^2\)

     

    => x = 15t2 -  \({15}\sqrt{3t}+x=0\)

     

    => t = \(\frac{15\sqrt{3}±\sqrt{675-4.42x}}{2.21}\)

     

    From the above-mentioned equation of time t, it is clear that the equation will not have a negative sign because if x is zero then then value of t will become zero. If the sign is negative then the value of time will become negative which is absurd to get. So, the equation of time will be as follows:

     

    ∴ t = \(\frac{15\sqrt{3}+\sqrt{675-4.42x}}{2.21}\)

     

    Now, from equation 11, we can write,

     

    y = 30 × sin sin 30° ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)\(\biggl(\)2. 21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t+ g\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = 15t - \(\biggl(\)1. 105 - 1. 02t + 0. 2365t+ 4. 9\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = 15t - 1. 105t+ 1. 02t- 0. 2365t- 4.9t2

     

    => y = 15t - 6t+ 1. 02t- 0. 2365t4

     

    => y = 15× \(\frac{15\sqrt{3+}\sqrt{675-4.42x}}{2.21}\) - 6 \((\frac{15\sqrt{3+}\sqrt{675-4.42x}}{2.21})^2\) + 1.02

     

     \((\frac{15\sqrt{3+}\sqrt{675-4.42x}}{2.21})^3\) - 0. 2365 \((\frac{15\sqrt{3+}\sqrt{675-4.42x}}{2.21})^4\)

     

    This is the equation of trajectory of javelin with air resistance for angle of projection equal to 30°.

     

    In second case, angle of projection is equal to 45° and initial velocity is 30 m/sec.

    From equation 10, we can write

     

    x = 30 × cos cos 45 ×t - 1. 105t2

     

    => x = \({15}\sqrt{2t}-1.105t^2\)

     

    => 1. 105t2 - \({15}\sqrt{2t}+x=0\)

     

    => t = \(\frac{15\sqrt{2±}\sqrt{450-4.42x}}{2.21}\)

     

    From the above-mentioned equation of time t, it is clear that the equation will not have a negative sign because if x is zero then then value of t will become zero. If the sign is negative then the value of time will become negative which is absurd to get. So, the equation of time will be as follows:

     

    ∴ t =\(\frac{15\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{450-4.42x}}{2.21}\)

     

    Now, from equation 11, we can write,

     

    y = 30 × sin sin 45° ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)\(\biggl(\)2. 21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t+ g\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = \({15}\sqrt{2t}\) -\(\biggl(\)1. 105 - 1. 02t + 0. 2365t+ 4. 9\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = \({15}\sqrt{2t}\) - 1.105t2 + 1.02t3 - 0.2365t4 - 4.9t2

     

    => y = \({15}\sqrt{2t}\) - 6t2 + 1.02t3 - 0.2365t4

     

    => y = 15\(\sqrt{2}×\) \(\frac{15\sqrt{2+}\sqrt{450-4.42x}}{2.21}\) - 6 \((\frac{15\sqrt{2+}\sqrt{450-4.42x}}{2.21})^2\)

     

    + 1.02\((\frac{15\sqrt{2+}\sqrt{450-4.42x}}{2.21})^3\)- 0. 2365\((\frac{15\sqrt{2+}\sqrt{450-4.42x}}{2.21})^4\)

     

    This is the equation of trajectory of javelin with air resistance for angle of projection equal to 45°.

     

    In third case, angle of projection is equal to 60° and initial velocity is 30 m/sec.

     

    From equation 10, we can write

     

    x = 30 × cos 60° ×t - 1. 105t2

     

    => x = 15t - 1. 105t2

     

    => 1. 105t- 15t + x = 0

     

    => t = \(\frac{15±\sqrt{225-4.42x}}{2.21}\)

     

    From the above-mentioned equation of time t, it is clear that the equation will not have a negative sign because if x is zero then then value of t will become zero. If the sign is negative then the value of time will become negative which is absurd to get. So, the equation of time will be as follows:

     

     ∴ t =\(\frac{15+\sqrt{225-4.42x}}{2.21}\)

     

    Now, from equation 11, we can write,

     

    y = 30 × sin 60° ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)\(\biggl(\)2. 21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t+ g\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = \({15}\sqrt{3t}\) - \(\biggl(\)1.105 - 1.02t + 0.2365t2 + 4.9t2\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = \({15}\sqrt{3t}\) - 6t+ 1. 02t- 0. 2365t4

     

    => y = \({15}\sqrt{3}\) \(×\frac{15+\sqrt{225-4.42x}}{2.21}\)- 6 \((\frac{15+\sqrt{225-4.42x}}{2.21})^2\) +

     

    1.02\((\frac{15+\sqrt{225-4.42x}}{2.21})^3\) - 0. 2365 \((\frac{15+\sqrt{225-4.42x}}{2.21})^4\)

     

    This is the equation of trajectory of javelin with air resistance for angle of projection equal to 60°.

     

    Time Period and Range of Javelin Throw for different projection with air resistance:

    In all the cases, the initial velocity of projection will be 30 m/sec.

     

    In first case,

     

    Angle of projection is 30°.

     

    From equation 11, we can write,

     

    y = u sin sin \(\theta\) ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)\(\biggl(\)2.21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t+ g\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    y = 30 × sin sin 30° ×t - \(\frac{1}{2}\)\(\biggl(\)2.21 - 2. 04t + 0. 473t+ g\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = 15t - \(\biggl(\)1. 105 - 1. 02t + 0. 2365t+ 4. 9\(\biggl)\)t2

     

    => y = 15t - 1. 105t+ 1. 02t- 0. 2365t- 4. 9t2

     

    => y = 15 t - 6t+ 1. 02t- 0. 2365t4

     

    In order to find the total time of flight, we have to find the value of t for y = 0:

     

    0. 2365t- 1. 02t+ 6t- 15t = 0

     

    Quartic equation

     

    ax+ bx3 + cx2 + dx + e = 0

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Figure 7 - Calculations Of Time Period

    Therefore, the time period is 2.96 sec. The value of time cannot be complex in nature thus we will ignore the complex roots of the equation. One root of t is zero because at time t = 0 the displacement of javelin in y direction was also zero (initial position).

     

    Again,

    From equation 10, we can write

     

    x = 30 × cos cos 30° ×t - 1. 105t2

     

    \(=>x= 15\sqrt{3t}-1.105t^2\)

     

    \(=>x= 15\sqrt{3}×2.96 - 1.105(2.96)^2\)

     

    => x = 67. 22 metre

     

    In second case,

     

    Angle of projection is 45°.

     

    From equation 11, we can write,

     

    \(y=u \,sin \,sin \,\theta ×t-\frac{1}{2}\biggl(2.21-2.04t+0.473t^2+g\biggl)t^2\)

     

    \(y=30× \,sin \,sin \,45° ×t-\frac{1}{2}\biggl(2.21-2.04t+0.473t^2+g\biggl)t^2\)

     

    \(=>y=15\sqrt{2t}-\biggl(1.105-1.02t+0.2365t^2+4.9\biggl)t^2\)

     

    \(=>y=15\sqrt{2t}-1.\,105t^2+1.\,02t^3-0.\,2365t^4-4.\,9t^2\)

     

    \(=>y=15\sqrt{2t}-6t^2+1.02t^3-0.2365t^4\)

     

    In order to find the total time of flight, we have to find the value of t for y = 0:

     

    0. 2365t- 1. 02t+ 6t- 21. 21t = 0

     

    Quartic equation

     

    ax4 + br3 + cx2 + dx + e = 0

    Figure 8 - Calculations Of Time Period

    Therefore, the time period is 3.81 sec. The value of time cannot be complex in nature thus we will ignore the complex roots of the equation. One root of t is zero because at time t = 0 the displacement of javelin in y direction was also zero (initial position).

     

    Again,

     

    From equation 10, we can write

     

    x = 30 × cos cos 45 ×t - 1. 105t2

     

    => x = \(15\sqrt{2t}-1.105t^2\)

     

    => x = \(15\sqrt{2}×3.81 - 1.105(3.81)^2\)

     

    => x = 64. 78 metre

     

    In third case,

     

    Angle of projection is 60°.

     

    From equation 11, we can write,

     

    \(y=u\,sin\,sin\, \theta ×t-\frac{1}{2}\biggl(2.21-2.04t + 0.473t^2+g\biggl)t^2\)

     

    \(y=30×\,sin\,sin\, 60° ×t-\frac{1}{2}\biggl(2.21-2.04t + 0.473t^2+g\biggl)t^2\)

     

    \(=>y=15\sqrt{3t}-\biggl(1.105-1.02t+0.2365t^2+4.9\biggl)t^2\)

     

    \(=>y=15\sqrt{3t}-1.105t^2+1.02t^3-0.2365t^4-4.9t^2\)

     

    \(=>y={15}\sqrt{3t}-6t^2+1.02t^3-0.2365t^4\)

     

    In order to find the total time of flight, we have to find the value of t for y = 0:

     

    0. 2365t- 1. 02t+ 6t- 25. 98t = 0

     

    Quartic equation

     

    ax4 + bx3 + cx2 + dx + e = 0

    Figure 9 - Calculations Of Time Period

    Therefore, the time period is 4.32 sec. The value of time cannot be complex in nature thus we will ignore the complex roots of the equation. One root of t is zero because at time t = 0 the displacement of javelin in y direction was also zero (initial position).

     

    Again,

     

    From equation 10, we can write

     

    x = 30 × cos cos 60° ×t - 1. 105t2

     

    => x = 15t - 1. 105t2

     

    => x = 15 × 4. 32 - 1. 105(4.32 )2

     

    => x = 44. 17 metre

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Graphical analysis

    Figure 10 - Showing Relationship Between Range And Wind Speed

    The equation of the curve showing the trendline is shown below:

     

    y = 0. 1019x2 + 6. 1162x + 91. 743

    Figure 11 - Showing Relationship Between Range And Wind Speed

    The equation of the curve showing the trendline is shown below:

     

    y = 0. 1019x2 - 6. 1162x + 91. 743

     

    Angle of Projection = 30°

     

    Initial Velocity = 30 m/sec

    Figure 12 - Trajectory Of Projectile Without Air Resistance

    Angle of Projection = 30°

     

    Initial Velocity = 30 m/sec

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Figure 13 - Trajectory Of Projectile With Air Resistance

    Angle of Projection = 45°

     

    Initial Velocity = 30 m/sec

    Figure 14 - Trajectory Of Projectile Without Air Resistance

    Angle of Projection = 45°

     

    Initial Velocity = 30 m/sec

    Figure 15 - Trajectory Of Projectile With Air Resistance

    Angle of Projection = 60°

     

    Initial Velocity = 30 m/sec

  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course

  • Figure 16 - Trajectory Of Projectile Without Air Resistance

    Angle of Projection = 60°

     

    Initial Velocity = 30 m/sec

    Figure 17 - Trajectory Of Projectile With Air Resistance

    Conclusion

    In this IA, we have studied the mathematics that should be considered while practise or training by a player to achieve success. In the first section of this IA, we have studied the effect of angle of projection in the range of the javelin throw. As we know that the range is the determining factor of the game. The player having largest range of javelin throw is declared as the winner. Angle of projection is one of the parameters that should be considered by the player during the game. As the angle of projection of javelin will always be an acute angle; thus, the range increases with the angle of projection till 45° and after that it starts to decrease and becomes zero at 90°. The angle at which the range should be maximum is 45°. So, the first section of the IA can be concluded as the range varies in sinusoidal nature and a player must project the javelin at 45° to attain maximum success.

     

    The only other parameter that should be considered by the player is the velocity of projection. It is very clear that more the velocity, greater will be the range. But the second section of the IA mainly deals with the effect of tailwind and head wind in the game. As the maximum wind speed observed till date in such athletic games is 5 m/s. Thus, taking a range of wind velocity from 0m/s to 5 m/s, we have concluded that, if it is tailwind, then the player will be greatly benefitted. Considering the controlled variables such as initial velocity of throw as 30m/s and angle of projection as 45°, we have concluded that, the range of javelin may vary between 91 metre to 125 metre. The initial velocity of throw is considered as 30 m/sec because for professional players, this is velocity of throw which is observed maximum. On the other hand, the angle of projection is set to 45° so that the maximum effect of wind on range can be obtained. For any other angle, the range will always be less than the observed values. The trendline obtained for establishing a relationship between range of javelin and wind speed while the wind is in the direction of javelin throw is:

     

    y = 0.1019x2 + 6.1162x + 91.743

     

    From the trendline, we can conclude that it is direct polynomial relationship of degree two, i.e., range of javelin increases with increase in wind speed. This is validated by the value of correlation constant R= 1. Thus, we can conclude that, the player while be very much benefitted in the game if there is a tail wind. In contrary, in case of a headwind, the effective velocity of the javelin will decrease and the range will also decrease. For the above-mentioned controlled variables, the range of javelin may vary between 91 metre to 64 metre. The trendline obtained for establishing a relationship between range of javelin and wind speed while the wind is in opposite direction of javelin throw is:

     

    y = 0.1019x2 - 6.1162x + 91.743

     

    From the trendline, we can conclude that it is inverse polynomial relationship of degree two, i.e., range of javelin decreases with increase in wind speed. This is validated by the value of correlation constant R= 1. Thus, we can conclude that, the player will suffer if there is any headwind during his throw. In a nutshell, we can sum up by stating if there is a head or tail wind by 5m/sec, the range of the javelin throw may vary by 60 metres considering the initial velocity of throw is 30m/sec, the wind speed is 5m/sec and the angle of projection is 45°.

     

    Lastly, from the analysis of air resistance on Javelin, we can see that, the air resistance in X – Direction is constant. Throughout the trajectory, the air resistance offered by the air is same thus, now, motion in X axis will experience a negative acceleration. On the other hand, air resistance in Y axis depends upon time t, i.e., the position of the particle. We know that, velocity in Y axis decreases in the first half of the trajectory. At the highest point, velocity in Y axis is zero and then it starts to increase. Also, the air resistance increases with increase in velocity. Thus, the air resistance in Y axis in the first half of the trajectory is decreasing and second half is increasing. Thus, we can conclude that, the motion of the javelin is not completely projectile, rather, the trajectory is asymmetric after introduction of air resistance. We have found the trajectories at 3 different angles so as to compare the effect of air resistance in trajectories of javelin. In the end, we can conclude that with an increase in angle of projection, the distortion in trajectory from the symmetric path increases. Due to this distortion, with angle of projection equal to 45 degrees, the range is not maximum yet.

    Bibliography

    • https://www.worldathletics.org/library
    • Fiorini, Paolo, and Zvi Shiller. "Motion planning in dynamic environments using the relative velocity paradigm." [1993] Proceedings IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. IEEE, 1993.
    • https://www.khanacademy.org/science/physics/one-dimensional-motion/displacement-velocity-time/a/what-is-velocity
    • https://www.khanacademy.org/science/physics/one-dimensional-motion/acceleration-tutorial/a/acceleration-article
    • Rohrabaugh, Gary B., and Scott A. Sherman. "Resolution independent vector display of internet content." U.S. Patent No. 7,210,099. 24 Apr. 2007.
    • Hancock, Harris. Theory of maxima and minima. Ginn, 1917.
    • https://www.desmos.com/calculator
    • http://www.alltime-athletics.com/mdecano.htm
    • https://www.softschools.com/formulas/physics/air_resistance_formula/85/#:~:text=It%20depends%20on%20the%20density,force%20is%20Newtons%20(N).
    • https://www.sportsrec.com/6995832/rules-and-regulations-for-the-javelin-throw
    • https://keisan.casio.com/exec/system/1181809416
  • Nail IB Video
    Ilan Grapel

    Tech & Law Grad Educator: Boost IB Math/CS Skills with Real-World Projects & Expertise!

    Video Course