Theory of Knowledge
Theory of Knowledge
13
Chapters
165
Notes
Chapter 1 - Knowledge & The Knower(Core)
Chapter 1 - Knowledge & The Knower(Core)
Chapter 2 - Knowledge & Technology(Optional)
Chapter 2 - Knowledge & Technology(Optional)
Chapter 3 - Knowledge & Language(Optional)
Chapter 3 - Knowledge & Language(Optional)
Chapter 4 - Knowledge & Politics(Optional)
Chapter 4 - Knowledge & Politics(Optional)
Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)
Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)
Chapter 6 - Knowledge & Indigenous Societies(Optional)
Chapter 6 - Knowledge & Indigenous Societies(Optional)
Chapter 7 - History(AoK)
Chapter 7 - History(AoK)
Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 8 - The Human Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 9 - The Natural Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 9 - The Natural Sciences(AoK)
Chapter 10 - The Arts(AoK)
Chapter 10 - The Arts(AoK)
Chapter 11 - Mathematics(AoK)
Chapter 11 - Mathematics(AoK)
Chapter 12 - ToK Exhibition
Chapter 12 - ToK Exhibition
Chapter 13 - ToK Essay
Chapter 13 - ToK Essay
IB Resources
Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)
Theory of Knowledge
Theory of Knowledge

Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)

Religion & Violence: Unraveling the Concept of 'Just War'

Word Count Emoji
753 words
Reading Time Emoji
4 mins read
Updated at Emoji
Last edited onย 5th Nov 2024

Table of content

Summary

Religion, at times, has been a justification for violent actions like war. This "Holy War" idea can mask the true, often intricate, causes of conflict. It can also lead to gross human rights violations as the divine authority believed to be backing the conflict reduces restraint and dehumanizes the opposition. In response, there's the concept of "Just War," a framework dating back to St. Augustine, aiming to balance ethical standards with violence. But this concept itself raises issues, especially regarding proportionality and its impact on civilian lives. A more peaceful alternative suggested is "Just Peace."

Holy war vs. just war

Holy War: is a term used when violent actions are justified using religious language. Here's how it works:

  • ๐ŸŒˆ Religious righteousness – Wars are justified as good fighting evil, which makes the situation seem black-and-white and divinely ordained.
  • ๐Ÿงฉ Obscuring complex causes – The actual reasons behind conflicts, such as access to resources, identity disputes, and diplomatic failures, are often hidden beneath religious justifications.
  • ๐Ÿ˜ˆ Dehumanizing the enemy – When the enemy is portrayed as evil, it reduces fighters' restraint and can lead to serious human rights violations.

Real-world example: The Crusades in the Middle Ages were often framed as Holy Wars, with the Christian forces believing they were fighting a divine cause against the "evil" Muslim empires.

 

Just War, on the other hand, is a concept that comes from St. Augustine. It attempts to merge Christian ethical ideals with the realities of conflict. The five key criteria for a just war are:

  • ๐ŸŽฏ Just cause - Is the reason for going to war justified?
  • ๐Ÿ‘‘ Proper authority - Is the war sanctioned by the right authority?
  • ๐Ÿšง Last resort - Have all other non-violent options been exhausted?
  • ๐ŸŽฒ Reasonable chance of success - Is there a realistic expectation that the war can be won?
  • โš–๏ธ Proportionality - Is the violence used proportional to the outcome desired?

Real-world example: World War II could be seen as a 'just war' - the war was fought against Nazi Germany due to their aggressive and expansive policies, their violation of international agreements, and human rights abuses.

Unlock the Full Content! File Is Locked Emoji

Dive deeper and gain exclusive access to premium files of Theory of Knowledge. Subscribe now and get closer to that 45 ๐ŸŒŸ

Nail IB's App Icon
IB Resources
Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)
Theory of Knowledge
Theory of Knowledge

Chapter 5 - Knowledge & Religion(Optional)

Religion & Violence: Unraveling the Concept of 'Just War'

Word Count Emoji
753 words
Reading Time Emoji
4 mins read
Updated at Emoji
Last edited onย 5th Nov 2024

Table of content

Summary

Religion, at times, has been a justification for violent actions like war. This "Holy War" idea can mask the true, often intricate, causes of conflict. It can also lead to gross human rights violations as the divine authority believed to be backing the conflict reduces restraint and dehumanizes the opposition. In response, there's the concept of "Just War," a framework dating back to St. Augustine, aiming to balance ethical standards with violence. But this concept itself raises issues, especially regarding proportionality and its impact on civilian lives. A more peaceful alternative suggested is "Just Peace."

Holy war vs. just war

Holy War: is a term used when violent actions are justified using religious language. Here's how it works:

  • ๐ŸŒˆ Religious righteousness – Wars are justified as good fighting evil, which makes the situation seem black-and-white and divinely ordained.
  • ๐Ÿงฉ Obscuring complex causes – The actual reasons behind conflicts, such as access to resources, identity disputes, and diplomatic failures, are often hidden beneath religious justifications.
  • ๐Ÿ˜ˆ Dehumanizing the enemy – When the enemy is portrayed as evil, it reduces fighters' restraint and can lead to serious human rights violations.

Real-world example: The Crusades in the Middle Ages were often framed as Holy Wars, with the Christian forces believing they were fighting a divine cause against the "evil" Muslim empires.

 

Just War, on the other hand, is a concept that comes from St. Augustine. It attempts to merge Christian ethical ideals with the realities of conflict. The five key criteria for a just war are:

  • ๐ŸŽฏ Just cause - Is the reason for going to war justified?
  • ๐Ÿ‘‘ Proper authority - Is the war sanctioned by the right authority?
  • ๐Ÿšง Last resort - Have all other non-violent options been exhausted?
  • ๐ŸŽฒ Reasonable chance of success - Is there a realistic expectation that the war can be won?
  • โš–๏ธ Proportionality - Is the violence used proportional to the outcome desired?

Real-world example: World War II could be seen as a 'just war' - the war was fought against Nazi Germany due to their aggressive and expansive policies, their violation of international agreements, and human rights abuses.

Unlock the Full Content! File Is Locked Emoji

Dive deeper and gain exclusive access to premium files of Theory of Knowledge. Subscribe now and get closer to that 45 ๐ŸŒŸ